|
What is FLAAR?
FLAAR
Digital Imaging Technology Center concentrates its
experience on the evaluation and testing of high quality scanners (35mm
slide scanners, flatbed scanners, drum scanners); 1200 dpi laser printers
for graphics design and printing photographs; and large format printers
of all kinds for limited editions of fine art and photo prints. We also
do evaluations of printers for signs, posters, banners and are gradually
moving into evaluations of printers for textiles.
FLAAR
Photo Archive tests and evaluates cameras (such as
Leica, Hasselblad, Rollei, Sinar, Cambo, Linhof, etc.), studio lighting
equipment, tripods and other professional photography equipment. FLAAR
Photo Archive is devoted to professional photography of sculpture in
jade, stone, ceramic, bone, and seashell of pre-Columbian art of Mesoamerica
as well as wildlife photography of Central America. FLAAR is nonprofit
and has been busily doing public education and research for over three
decades.
Once
the FLAAR Photo Archive and the FLAAR Digital Imaging Technology Center
have established which equipment, hardware and software is the best
for each specific purchase and need, then FLAAR Marketing & Consulting
offers people assistance to find the particular product which is what
will produce the kind of prints that they need. We do this based on
actual practice, experience, by visiting other companies that also produce
fine art giclée prints, by attending the leading international computer
graphic and digital imaging trade shows such as Photokina in Cologne,
CeBIT computer trade show in Hannover, DRUPA printer trade show in Duesseldorf, Seybold, Comdex in Las Vegas, PMA
etc. At the trade shows it is possible to study and compare the hardware
and software and meet pertinent people in the companies that make the
best equipment. When your needs and questions can better be answered
by an experienced person who actually makes the product you are looking
for, then we forward your questions to that person because they usually
know more about how to use and set up the hardware or software. From
our experience we also estimate many of your "unasked questions" which will occur to you later. Right now you are mainly interested in
getting the right printer and RIP. But once you are happily using your
new system, you will eventually wish more information about color management,
you may wish to take a training course, you may want to know more about
paper, inks, and other accessories. We test the various inks, media,
laminators and/or study these at each trade show, so we already have
worked out which are the best of the companies in each field. These
are the companies we judge are the most appropriate to assist you in
learning more about large format printing. Thus we will follow up later
in the year with additional information on the other items you will
wish to learn about as you yourself get further along in using large
format printers.
Often
the incoming e-mail provide tips themselves, from the experience of
our readers. These tips can help countless other people so we save your
suggestions and combine your tips with those of others to form "chapters" in the book that we would like to prepare. Exerpts are also used to
provide information on the various FLAAR web sites.
Naturally it is usually necessary to prune and extract the kernel of
your observations, so we may need to edit your comments. By sending
your e-mail to ask for assistance you agree to share your comments with
our readers, whether on our web pages or in the book. Don't worry, your
name will not be used in association with your comments in our publications.
No extract that we print in our sites nor in our book includes your
name. Besides, we use only about 25% of what comes to us for the book
or "notable quotable from readers."
FLAAR
receives equipment for evaluation from BetterLight, Calumet (Calumet
Photographic/Calument Digital Solutions), ColorSpan,
Sinar Bron, Leica, Schneider Kreuznach, Encad, Epson USA, Hewlett-Packard,
Ilford, Rexam, American Ink Jet, Hahnemuehle,
BEST,
PosterJet, Onyx Graphics, GretagMacbeth and more other companies than
we can list here. Printers have been provided courtesy of HP, Epson,
MacDermid ColorSpan, and Encad.
When
we discuss hardware, software, and accessories we tend to know the items
best that are physically in our studios. Also when we recommend a particular
make or model of equipment, we tend to know more about the printers,
RIP´s, and associated equipment that we ourselves use daily. Don't
be surprised if we obtain better results from a particular scanner or
printer than other people that you ask about the same make and model.
This is because when you send your images to a commercial printer, often
they will print it as is at the faster speeds. But fast speed = lower
quality. Of course the results may look okay, but if we had the same
image, since we do everything at the highest quality modes (which implies
slightly slower print speed) we usually get a better result. For example,
no banding at all, better colors, and we tend to use a better paper.
This is how we can obtain exhibit-quality prints from an Encad even
at 300 dpi (don't worry, there are much better printers, and the better
ones often don't cost as much as an Encad either, and are easier to
maintain). This is just an example because readers often write "but
people tell me that xyz printer is not appropriate for fine art printing..."
That is because commercial printers can charge you a higher premium
by using an Iris or Roland, yet more often than not they are using the
higher quality dpi because most artists and photographers don't notice
the difference. This even happened to us, we sent an image to a major
giclée printing company and it came back looking not much better than
the identical image that we did on our Hewlett-Packard. The giclée printing company subsequently admitted they did it at 720
dpi and not 1440 dpi. We checked with another artist and the same thing
happened to him at another giclée printing company.
Many
of the people who write ask where they can buy the equipment that we
use and/or recommend. Since FLAAR itself does not sell equipment we
don't always know the specific retail prices since we tend to buy at
wholesale price or we get an educational discount (it helps being at
a university). But knowing where to buy is as important as knowing what
to buy so we recommend pertinent outlets when we have a good experience
with that particular company. As our main evaluation studios are in
Germany, which has the highest postage rates in the world and in Guatemala
where its slow to send things internationally, it is easier when the
company itself sends their catalogs to you. When it is evident from
your e-mail that you are looking for a particular product (such as a
scanner, a printer, a RIP) then we ask the companies to send you the
catalog, as that saves FLAAR from having to pay the postage and office
overhead expenses.
Hewlett-Packard
large format printer division is a sponsor of the educational program
of FLAAR to enable us to provide information about large format printer
technology. HP provides equipment for FLAAR to use in its evaluations
and training programs but HP is not present at the tests, does not participate
in the tests, and is not informed of the full results of the tests until
these results are published on the pages of the FLAAR websites. www.fineartgicléeprinters.org
was founded as an independent source of information based on actual
use of the products in an actual studio. You may note that we do not
parrot corporate PR; we do not use PR shots provided by the companies
(not even by Hewlett-Packard). Furthermore this site is open to sponsorship
by any company whose products meet our standards.
New
to fine art giclée printing?
Need
some help figuring out fine art printing? Don't worry, no one can pronounce
giclée properly because its a made-up phoney French word anyway. giclée
just means squirted ink. The information and answers to all following
questions are in the FLAAR reports. Just find the inquiry-survey form,
send it in by e-mail. That gives you entry to a special menu of PDF
reports. You can either download these or ask for a direct response
from the FLAAR staff by e-mail (PDF downloads are instant; personal
response takes 3 to 5 days; we answer 95% of all incoming e-mail, as
long as you ask about large format printers; we don't handle cheap desktop
printers). There is no charge for the First
Level Reports
QUESTIONS
about fine art prints, about printing limited editions of your paintings,
or your photographs, digital fine art, how to scan?
What
equipment do I use to scan or digitize my paintings or photographs?
Again
it helps to know whether you will be printing the fine art prints yourself,
are you considering acquiring your own large format printer, and if
so what size (24" 36" larger than 36"). If you do your
own prints at home or in your studio you can accomplish far better results.
We know this for a fact since two tests with commercial fine art giclée
printers resulted in finding out that they used the lesser modes (720
dpi) and did not use the top fine art mode (1440 dpi). In other words,
you pay lots of money and in two instances we documented you get lower
quality prints if you pay someone else to do them. Conclusions: if you
purchase or lease your own large format printer you can get top quality
for your own art, better than at some commercial places. Surely many
excellent fine art printing establishments do 1440 dpi printing, but
both of the two that we tested did not.
Which
printer is a production workhorse?
This
means, which other printers may break down or burn out if they do a
print run of 400 copies (or even 100 copies). Did you know that some
printers are so slow they will produce only about 5 to 10 prints an
entire day?
Which
printer is best for a first-time user?
This
means I am new to all of this,I have read about all those fancy printers,
but how can I actually use one? By the way, there is one printer we
use ourselves precisely because it is idiot-proof.
What
is absolutely the best printer if money is no object?
This
means I am dreaming about doing fine art prints with a top of the line
printer, but of course in reality I just want to know about these fancy
printers. In real life I would prefer a printer that is easier to use
and does not require paying a technician or operator $50,000 a year
to keep the printer running.
How
do I paint on top of an inkjet print? How do I make an inkjet print
as basis for my subsequent painting?
We
can more easily answer this question if we know whether you wish to
buy a printer for yourself (which in the long run is a far better idea)
or whether you intend to have someone else do your prints (more difficult,
since you can't control the output as well if someone else prints them?).
Which
printer should I use, Epson 9000, Epson 7000, Roland Hi Color Fi, ColorSpan
XII, ColorSpan giclée printer, Iris GPrint giclée printer?
"How
come no other printer claims their prints will last for centuries and
are better than prints from a darkroom? How can Epson produce a cheap
printer that is better than (as they claim) a LightJet, which costs
perhaps $100,000.00 or more?" What are the untold downsides of
the Epson 7500, Epson 9500, and the Epson 10000? FLAAR inspected these
printers in detail during trade show in Germanys plus we have received
information from a variety of sources since then. Just send an e-mail
and you get all the information in reply (on busy weeks please allow
about 2 days to get our reply).
Last
updated Jan. 15, 2003,
Previuws updates Nov. 15, 2002 , Aug. 18, 2001 |